<img loading="lazy" alt="Post List Summary Featured Image" src="https://3280432.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hubfs/3280432/Gavel%20and%20Computer%20Cropped.png">

Why NYC Businesses Face ADA Website Lawsuits and Wage & Hour Claims

By Michael Samuel, Esq. on Jul 10, 2025
Topics: Web Accessibility, ADA Website Compliance

0 Comments

In today's digital-first world, businesses face growing legal exposure on multiple fronts, many of which intersect in unexpected ways. For companies operating in New York City, two significant areas of vulnerability are Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) website accessibility compliance and wage and hour employment claims.

While these issues may seem unrelated on the surface, they share some striking parallels and practical overlaps that businesses should be aware of to avoid costly litigation.

The Expanding Scope of ADA Website Compliance

The ADA, initially enacted in 1990, has evolved far beyond its original focus on physical accessibility. Today, the Department of Justice (DOJ) and numerous courts interpret Title III of the ADA to apply to business websites and mobile apps, requiring digital properties to be accessible to individuals with disabilities.

WCAG (Web Content Accessibility Guidelines) 2.1 Level AA has become the de facto standard for measuring ADA website compliance. Sites that fail to meet these standards may face lawsuits from individuals with visual, auditory, or motor impairments who cannot easily navigate digital content.

According to UsableNet's end-of-year report, digital accessibility lawsuits reached 4,187 in 2024, with 2025 on pace to hit 4,975 lawsuits by the end of the year. 

Download the full 2025 Midyear ADA Lawsuit Report here.

The number of cases growing yearly from 2018 to the middle of 2025. The numbers are as follows: 2018: 2314; 2019: 2890; 2020: 3503; 2021: 4011; 2022: 4035; 2023: 4630; 2024: 4187; 2025: 4975, estimated by the end of the year.

Figure: Growth in ADA digital accessibility lawsuits from 2018 to 2025 (estimated).
The number of web and mobile accessibility cases has increased steadily

Why NYC Businesses Are Particularly at Risk

New York City has become a hotbed for ADA digital accessibility claims due to several factors:

  • High volume of small businesses with consumer-facing websites
  • A well-organized plaintiffs' bar actively filing accessibility claims
  • Judicial precedent generally favors website accessibility under Title III

At the same time, many of these same businesses are heavily dependent on hourly labor, often employing workers who may also bring wage and hour claims under state and federal law.

The Growing Threat of Wage & Hour Litigation

New York State's wage and hour laws are among the most protective in the country. Wage theft, unpaid overtime, misclassification of independent contractors, and failure to maintain proper payroll records are frequent sources of legal exposure for employers.

The Department of Labor (DOL) and private plaintiffs frequently pursue claims under:

  • New York Labor Law (NYLL)
  • The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)
  • Misclassification statutes for contractors vs. employees

In recent years, many NYC employers have faced class action claims seeking significant back pay, liquidated damages, and attorneys' fees — often resulting in settlements exceeding six figures.

Parallel Risks: ADA and Wage & Hour Compliance

Issue

ADA Website Compliance

Wage & Hour Claims

Strict Liability Terms

Courts rarely require intent to establish ADA violations.

 Employers may violate wage laws without bad faith. 
High Volume of Plaintiff's Counsel   Many plaintiffs’ firms actively target ADA violations.   Numerous firms specialize in wage theft litigation. 
Fee-Shifting Provisions  Defendants may be required to pay plaintiffs’ legal fees.   FLSA and NYLL mandate attorneys’ fees for employees. 
Class Action Potential 

ADA claims may involve injunctive relief on a class-wide basis.

 Wage claims often proceed as collective or class actions. 
Compliance Complexity  Evolving WCAG standards create ongoing technical obligations. 

Complex and changing federal, state, and city laws govern wages and hours.

 

Proactive Compliance Can Protect Against Both

The good news is that proactive compliance measures can mitigate both risks simultaneously. For example:

  • Website Accessibility Audits: Investing in a qualified accessibility audit can reduce ADA exposure. Vendors like UsableNet provide comprehensive digital accessibility services to help businesses align with WCAG standards.
  • Wage & Hour Compliance Reviews: Conducting internal payroll audits and consulting experienced employment counsel can uncover misclassification or wage violations before they lead to litigation.
  • Training for HR and IT Staff: Educating staff about legal requirements on both fronts helps reduce inadvertent violations.
  • Vendor Agreements: Ensuring that web developers and payroll processors are contractually obligated to comply with ADA and wage regulations can provide an additional layer of protection.

Why Overlapping Compliance Pays Off

Often, businesses wait until a demand letter or lawsuit arrives to address these risks, but by that point, options are limited and expensive. Investing early in ADA accessibility and wage law compliance may seem costly upfront, but it's far cheaper than defending simultaneous lawsuits on both fronts.

For example, our firm, The Samuel Law Firm, has seen firsthand how businesses that take proactive steps often avoid becoming easy targets for serial plaintiffs.

Number of cases in CA, NY, and FL between January and June. Jan: 27 in CA, 245 in NY, 61 in FL. Feb: 14 in CA, 269 in NY, 58 in FL. March: 25 in CA, 255 in NY, 114 in FL.  April: 9 in CA, 243 in NY, 81 in FL. May: 21 in CA, 247 in NY, 107 in FL. June: 8 in CA, 170 in NY, 65 in FL.

Figure: ADA website lawsuits filed in California, New York, and Florida (Jan–June 2025).
New York continues to lead in volume of digital accessibility cases, with over 1,400 lawsuits filed in the first half of 2025, nearly five times more than California and Florida combined.
 

Conclusion

ADA website compliance and wage & hour laws may target different conduct, but both reflect a broader shift toward aggressive regulatory enforcement and private litigation. In New York City, where plaintiffs' lawyers are well-organized and courts tend to favor plaintiffs, businesses must remain vigilant.

By treating compliance holistically — addressing both digital accessibility and employment practices — businesses can significantly reduce their legal exposure and focus on growth rather than defense.

Stay Ahead of Legal Trends with UsableNet's 2025 Midyear Report 

Explore the latest developments in digital accessibility litigation and discover why proactive compliance is essential.

Download the 2025 Midyear report on digital accessibility lawsuits

Michael Samuel, Esq.

Michael Samuel, Esq.

Michael Samuel is an attorney with The Samuel Law Firm, a New York City-based practice focusing on wage & hour law, employment litigation, and ADA defense.

Need to improve digital usability, accessibility or performance? We can help.
Partner with us. Get in touch.